Mary Kay Sucks: The Myth of Neutrality
December 29, 2006 at 6:11 pm (MaryKaySucks Chronicles, blog series)
One day while perusing the internet I was struck by a blog called Mary Kay Sucks. As I have stated in my previous posts on this blog I had never sold or even purchased Mary Kay products and yet I was drawn to the site.
So I’ve been spending some time on this blog which is now called Pink Truth, a name which I find now suits the mission much more aptly.
When I began this series and began to spend the time on Pink Truth I really felt as though I had a neutral stance. After all, I had nothing to gain nor lose in this argument. I was Switzerland. It was fun to watch and fun to comment on what I saw.
The truth is, however that I am not sure how one can truly stay neutral in this case. Neutral implies coasting, cruising through without propelling oneself, moving without noise or effort. As I read the stories of these women and those of the women who still engage in Mary Kay Cosmetics I was moved by the tender and fragile synchonicity of the pieces as they moved together. So much depends upon the other.
At the risk of sounding provacative there has existed a symbiotic relationship between MK as a community and MKsucks. When something happens in one universe it directly applies to the other. Sometimes this would be clothing worn by upper ranking consultants, sometimes it would revolve around emails or notices that had gone out but it was a ripple effect. I often wonder, if the ProMk people and MK corporate had just ignored PT would it just have fizzled to a close at some point? If this was merely a small group of “disgruntled” former and current consultants who “didn’t work hard enough” then certainly, the blog itself would have floundered when the participants felt finished with lamenting, yes? We really can only run on the fuel of negativity for so long and then, I believe most of us will meander toward a different avenue.
It’s the television mentality. We can only watch the same show for a length of time and then we get bored, get a life, get interested in something else, get rid of cable…we are a fickle but drama-loving lot and there is much drama to be found if only we look.
But where I feel PinkTruth is headed is much deeper than that. This is not a television show, a fictional program which ends when the film stops or we stop watching, whichever comes first. This is a chronical of the lives of real people; good and bad and in between. It began as a place to gather and has now progressed into a place to greet. The oldtimers in PT wait at the door, no longer terribly concerned with who is wearing what to Seminar, no longer grousing about which products are being discontinued. They wait at the door to greet newcomers. They answer questions patiently if not pointedly. They sit as the wisewoman in their tent, listening to people as they enter and offer their experience as testimony. Make no mistake, they are driven and have purpose but it it not quite as one might think. It is not a drive to destroy but rather rebuild that which they and others have lost. It is not a purpose of revenge but rather of restoration.
As with most things and people, they fail at times. They fall into old trends of catty commentary and joke-making but it becomes more and more incidental as time progresses. It becomes footnote instead of fodder.
I have heard it said that the word “Protestant” as it refers to the Church is no longer relevant. The Protestant Church is truly no longer protesting, they are creating something of their own. In a sense, Pink Truth is doing this as well. They are no longer merely an extension of the community of Mary Kay Constultants, albeit the unhappy arm of the community.
In the face of injustice how do we respond? Can we truly be neutral in this?


